We have been regulars here for years. The salad bar is consistently the best around. We have tried many salad bars from other supper clubs. The bartenders are great. Last night we came for German Night. My schnitzel with mustard cream sauce was wonderful. Our server Deanna was friendly and attentive. I included a picture from Christmas time to show the coziness inside.

We went to Wallace lake supper club for a birthday celebration . Delicious wine , the seating was very close together but it felt like family . Every one told us about the world famous salad bar and we were excited to try . It was fully stocked with lots of options . Service was great and the staff were friendly . The steak and prime rib were just okay .

We took our kids for their first Wisconsin Supper Club experience and I have to say this place didn't disappoint. The bar and dining room were a quintessential supper club experience, wood paneling everywhere. The bar was a nice size and very open. The salad bar was a nice addition to the meal. We started with frog legs and cheese curds. The frog legs were very tender and tasty. The cheese curds were really good. Then I had the French onion soup and it was really good. Lots of onions and a good broth taste. Beef Wellington was very tender, my waitress suggested ordering rare and it was a perfect medium rare. Fork tender. Overall a great evening with family

McHenry's on Mondays, a pop-up that takes over Wallace Lake Supper Club on Monday nights, has been posting some tasty looking food on social media, particularly a Chicken Caesar sandwich. I looked at their menu online and saw another item that sounded interesting (more on that below) so I decided to give them a try. Ultimately I ended up ordering the chicken Caesar sandwich and prime rib bites as an appetizer. Unfortunately, their online menu lists a couple different items that they don't actually serve. Specifically, I asked about a certain pizza and three different employees told me they had never heard of it. In addition, the chicken Caesar sandwich that I ordered came with grated parmesan, but the same picture they post week after week on social media clearly shows shaved parmesan. A manager told me that it used to come with shaved and now comes with grated. If that's the case, don't keep posting the same old picture cause it's misleading. Also, the prime rib bites I ended up ordering are not on their menu, but has been a "special" that they've had since December according to social media. At that point it's been nine months and you might as well put it on the regular menu. Finally, their hours according to social media are 4pm to 8pm. Really, though, that means the bar opens at 4pm, but the kitchen doesn't open until 4:30pm. Why they can't be the same I don't understand and it was a waste of half an hour since I got there at 4pm. All that said, the food was great. The prime rib bites were lightly breaded then fried. Little pieces of heaven. Even with the parmesan issue I enjoyed the sandwich. They butterflied the chicken breast and blackened it so it seemed like a ton of good flavor between the dressing and the blackened chicken. Now that some expectations have been set for me, I would go back for the food. I wouldn't go right when social media says they open up because that's obviously not accurate if you want to order food right away and I wouldn't trust the online menu. The food was worth the frustration.

Although I'm not sure I'd define it as a true supper club (at least in the traditional sense) - don't let let that throw you. Really great meal at Wallace Lake Supper Club. The Pan Fried Walleye is worth the drive from anywhere. It's truly the best I've ever had. The ribs (ordered with the sauce on the side)- moist, tender, perfectly seasoned along side a small order of fried shrimp. The Baked French Onion Soup and salad bar - delicious. They also pour a great drink and when you walk in the door can see the Prime Rib Aging Case. Service was great, staff was warm and inviting. From the dining room there is a great view of the lake and once the weather cooperates there is outdoor dining and a fire pit. We're looking forward to returning. I'd have that walleye every day if I could.